Why This Reddit Robot Says You Shouldn't Buy a Soundbar

Why This Reddit Robot Says You Shouldn't Buy a Soundbar

The rise of soundbars and Home Theater in a Box (HTiB) systems has sparked a fiery debate among audio enthusiasts. We’re here to tell you about a hot take from a popular subreddit, a perspective we tend to agree with. 

A bold perspective comes from Reddit's r/hometheater, a community with over a million members. This group has firmly positioned itself against these all-in-one solutions like soundbars and HTiB.  

R/HomeTheater: Hot Take

The subreddit's autoresponder robot posts an automatic message in response to new posts: "99.9% of the time Soundbars or HTiB systems are not a good investment."  

Why Doesn't the Robot Like Soundbars?

Soundbars and HTiB solutions are often marketed for their convenience and space-saving features, but these benefits come with notable compromises in sound quality and often power.

One of the main criticisms is the lack of authentic stereo separation—a key component in immersive listening experiences. This is because soundbars typically combine multiple speakers into a single unit, limiting their ability to project sound from distinct spatial locations. Consequently, they fail to deliver the depth and clarity that more traditional setups offer. 

What Exactly is a Home Theater in a Box? 

HTiB systems are packaged home theater solutions that include everything you need to set up a home cinema, such as an AV Receiver / Amplifier and several speakers. While they promise an all-in-one package, they often feature lower-quality components that can't compete with the fidelity provided by separate, high-quality components. They might be tempting for those seeking a quick and easy setup, but they fall short in delivering the high-definition audio experience that true enthusiasts crave. 

A Superior Alternative

Audioengine Home Music Systems “2.0” and “2.1” 

For those interested in both clear detailed music playback and a cinematic audio experience featuring deep bass, Audioengine's HD5 and HD6 Home Music Systems offer a compelling alternative.  

As the auto responder describes, our powered speaker systems are called “2.0” systems in this context. These systems are not only home theater ready but also provide the rich, authentic sound of a traditional Hi-Fi stereo setup. Each unit integrates seamlessly, eliminating the need for an external amplifier, which simplifies setup without compromising on quality. 

Adding a subwoofer like the Audioengine S8 can transform your listening experience, called a 2.1 system.

Our previous blog, "Why Not All Subwoofers Are Created Equally" discusses how pairing the right subwoofer with your speakers can significantly enhance the depth and texture of sound. This combination not only excels in delivering powerful cinematic experiences but also reproduces music with the precision and fidelity expected from high-end audio systems. 

Why Choose Audioengine? 

Audioengine's HD5 and HD6 are designed to offer a versatile solution that fits virtually any audio setup. They stand apart with their built-in amplifiers, high-quality drivers, and robust construction that ensures longevity and performance. Whether you're watching a blockbuster hit or enjoying your favorite symphony, these speakers deliver clear, room-filling sound. Their ease of use, coupled with their expansion capabilities, makes them an excellent investment for audio lovers looking to build a system that grows with their needs. 


While soundbars and HTiB systems might appeal to those looking for a straightforward, plug-and-play solution, they simply cannot match the superior quality and flexibility offered by more dedicated setups.  

Audioengine's approach provides a bridge between professional-level sound engineering and consumer accessibility, making true high-fidelity sound attainable for home theaters and music enthusiasts alike. By choosing Audioengine, you're not just buying a product; you're investing in an experience that brings every detail of sound to life, be it in movies or music. 

Back to blog

Leave a comment

Please note, comments need to be approved before they are published.